Comic Review: Morning Glories TPB Vol 1 Who knew prep school would be so thrilling!

Comic Review: Morning Glories     TPB Vol 1

Writer(s): Nick Spencer

Artist(s): Joe Eisma, Rodin Equejo (covers)

US Publisher: Image Comics (March 1, 2011)

The Plot:

Morning Glory Academy is one of the most prestigious prep schools in the country… but something sinister and deadly lurks behind its walls. When six gifted, but troubled, students arrive, they find themselves trapped and fighting for their lives as the secrets of the academy reveal themselves!

The Review:

I’ve lost track of how many reviewers have compared this comic as a cross between the TV show LOST and… (Insert something else that strikes your fancy here).

Yes, Nick Spencer uses similar narrative threads and stylings when concocting this tale of mystery and thrills, and much like in the before mentioned TV show, surprises spring out of nowhere, and just when you thought you were heading in one directions, there is slide of hand, and you are taken somewhere else altogether.

And if you like thrills and shock, it is a pleasant experience.

But this type of tales have a longer tradition than just LOST. Heck, in my lifetime I can think of The Fugitive, where a man wakes up and doesn’t know why he is being pursued by the police, or better yet, the cult favorite THE FUGITIVE (google and then get! You will be surprised), where really nothing was what it seemed, and we had to wait for lots of twists and turns before things bothered making sense.

But Morning Glories is NOT a one trick pony, and for that we have the character treatments that Nick Spencer regal us with. Although most of the characters in this book start out being presented to the reader as stereotypes of a cliché (imagine that) little by little, story by story it gets expanded upon, and we are shown believable characters, people we can empathize with, that gain our interest and we are made to want to know more about them.

That’s the main strength of the series: The plot is topsy-turvy and the characters are amazingly well rounded.

The strength and complexity of the characters is such that the reader will be able to shift between backstory and current mystery not feeling like they have to shift gears but more like they are getting double the doses of the same treat. Background stories are as compelling as current event thrills, and that’s rare, to find writers who manage to stay away from fillers.

The floppies published covers by Rodin Esquejo, but the interior art was done by Joe Eisma. Well, I have to say that although Mr. Eisma is a competent artist, Image did gives a bit of a baitandswitch feel here. Joe Eisma is not as polished and matured an artists and doesn’t live up to the expectations that Mr. Esquejo rises. This is not a matter of having Richard Corben do the cover and Berni Writghson so the interior art. These two artists are not at the same level, and I’ve read comments and talked to acquaintances who were a bit put off by this.

I AM NOT SAYING that the art of Mr Eisma is bad. I am reporting that some people felt cheated, and that I can understand why. For me the art took a second seat to the story of Nick Spencer, and it never got in the way of letting me enjoy the story. Yes, there were panels where expressions could’ve been more defined, there were pages where I noticed that physical appearances were too rigid and little things like that, but in general, I found an artist in development, who is finding his voice, and that is always a welcome thing.

My main quibble with Trade Paper Back is where are the covers by Rodin Esquejo? They were there gracing the individual floppies and were gorgeous! The TPB knows it is selling well focusing on the story that captivated so many audiences, but the covers would’ve given the book an extra value that art lovers would’ve truly appreciated.

So, on my Critic’s rating,   Morning Glories gets

8 STARS out of 10

Advertisements

4 Comments Add yours

  1. Joe Eisma says:

    Hey, thanks for the review. I appreciate all your thoughts. But, ‘bait and switch’ on the art? I guess DC did that with JG Jones and Pia Guerra on Y the Last Man, or James Jean and Mark Buckingham on Fables? There are plenty of books that have different cover artists than interior artists, and Rodin’s covers are fully painted, so of course my lineart isn’t going to look anything like his. Sorry if you felt cheated.

    1. mtda80 says:

      Haha, pretty cool response. Those covers really do pop though, so I guess I understand the “bait and switch.” I have just now started enjoying this series, keep up the great work!

  2. ComicWatcher says:

    Wow, woo slow down, partner.
    I wonder if this is another case of an artist being too sensitive, in which case, I understand, and I sympathize, and want to ask you to read the review again slowly and after a few breaths, and see that there was very little (if any) bile in the words.

    I like your art, Joe. On a personal not, I can say that I don’t love it. I can also say I don’t count you among my favorite artists, but then again, my list is pretty small so no offense on that, and it shouldn’t bother you.
    But regarding Baitandswitch covers, I’ll explain that is a pet-peeve of mine that I cover a lot on the blog, and it doesn’t mean when the covers are different than the content. It means, (and I stated that in other entries in the blog) as I said with the Wrightson-Corben example, when the styles are way different.
    In the case of Morning Glories, I admit that it may not be too much of a stretch, but the reader community has voiced a concerned about the difference in this book.
    I’ve read a lot of harsher reviews on your art on other sites, even haters, and I want to express that I actually do see your potential. I believe you are still in the process of becoming an amazing artist. Think John Byrne and Alan Davis great. But we are still catching you in the formative years, when you are still formulating the voice that makes you distinct.
    And as you should know by now this field will offer you lots and lots of opinions (remember that saying that opinions are like assholes, and all that?) and you should by now know that sometimes you will get praises, and sometimes knocks. Take what makes you stronger and what helps you grow, and try to ignore what doesn’t help your artistic progression.
    I just want to go on record stating that I believe we are witnessing the beginning of your rise as an artist, not a failed attempt at something.
    The ComicWatcher.

  3. Humberto Torris says:

    Wonderful web site. A lot of useful information here. I am sending it to several friends ans also sharing in delicious. And thanks for your effort!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s